An appellate panel of the Sixth District Appeals court has ruled that a former rape suspect may proceed with his civil suit against the San Jose Police Department, the Mercury News reports. Back in 2008 Michael Kerkeles was accused of raping a mentally disabled woman in March of 2005. As a part of the investigation, Officer Christian of the San Jose Police Department used a fake DNA report showing that Kerkeles semen was collected from the scene of the crime. This was used (unsuccessfully) to illicit a confession from the suspect.
The practice of falsifying police report sand medical documents is not illegal in the investigative stage of a criminal matter. However, the false report in this case was used against Mr. Kerkeles in the prosecution of his criminal matter. At the preliminary hearing, the deputy district attorney assigned to the case called Officer Christian to the stand. He testified as to the authenticity of the crime lab report and that it accurately reflected DNA evidence collected at the crime scene. The crime lab report was the same used to illicit a confession and was completely fabricated.
During trial Mr. Kerkeles' attorneys learned that the report was a fake and as a result the District Attorney drop the charges.
Kerkeles filed suit against the San Jose Police alleging, among others, fraud, wrongful arrest, prosecution and false imprisonment. The law suit was delayed by a Superior Court judge who accepted Officer Christian's later testimony that he forgot the DNA report was falsified. The Appellate Court disagreed and said that both Officer Christian and the District Attorney knew or should have known that the report was a fake.
The San Jose Police Department has since prohibited its investigating officers from using fake reports as a part of their criminal investigations.
If you have been charged with a crime you need legal representation. Call the Law Offices of Erik Steven Johnson for a free consultation at (408) 246-3004. Know Your Rights!
